Stop Signs

My in-laws were visiting us from Long Island New York this weekend.  I had to go buy some car parts and accessories at Canadian Tire and invited my father-in-law to come along for the ride and keep me company.  He's a retired spy for the city of New York or at least that is what he hints at whenever we asked them what exactly he did for a living.  He's a fun guy to be with and conversations with him are always interesting.

As we drove through the rain and endless stop signs in the West Island he told me that he had just finished his drivers’ refresher's course.  Both he and my mother-in-law take the course every four years which qualifies them for a 10% discount in their automobile insurance.  Although I'm not aware of any such incentives in Québec it might be a good idea to implement such a program here.

He was amazed to see the number of four-way stop signs at Montréal intersections.  In New York they are quite a bit rarer.  Nonetheless four-way stop signs were a topic of discussion at his recent refresher course.  He said that everyone was confused by the right-of-way rules and even the instructor wasn't entirely sure who goes first if everyone arrives at a stop sign at the same time.

The Highway Safety Code of Québec has several paragraphs devoted to stop signs.  Oddly enough paragraph number 368 which is stop sign rule sends you off to paragraph 360 which in turn is completed by paragraphs 369 and 370. 

No one ever said the law was easy.

Paragraph 368 of the Code reads as follows:

Stop sign.

368.  The driver of a road vehicle or any person riding a bicycle must stop his vehicle when facing a stop sign, and comply with section 360.

One might think that when drafting this ever important piece of legislation

the lawmakers might have included the details that could be found in paragraph 360.  They did not.  So let's look at paragraph 360.  It reads as follows:

Flashing red light.

360.  Unless otherwise directed by a sign or signal, when facing a flashing red light, the driver of a road vehicle or any person riding a bicycle must stop his vehicle and yield the right of way to a vehicle approaching on another roadway that is entering the intersection, or is so close that it constitutes a hazard.

Essentially, when you come up to a stop sign you must stop your vehicle and yield the right-of-way to the other car if it is already entering the intersection or is so close to you that your proceeding through the intersection would cause an accident.  This rule applies when you have a stop sign and the other guys don't.  Interestingly enough all of the stop sign rules apply equally to bicycle riders and automobile drivers.

Sections 369 and 370 of The Code tell you what to do when you come to a two or four-way stop sign intersection.

Two-way stop sign.

369.  At an intersection regulated by stop signs installed for only one roadway, the driver of a road vehicle or any person riding a bicycle who is facing a stop sign must stop his vehicle and yield the right of way to pedestrians and cyclists crossing the roadway he is about to cross or enter.

Four-way stop sign.

370.  At an intersection regulated by stop signs for all directions, the driver of a road vehicle or any person riding a bicycle must stop his vehicle and yield the right of way to any vehicle having reached the intersection before him. He must also yield the right of way to pedestrians crossing the roadway he is about to cross or enter.

While all this law may be interesting for some it does not actually answer my father-in-law's question as to who goes first when everybody reaches the intersection at a four-way stop at the same time.  Here then are the three simple rules to remember when coming to a four-way stop.

Rule number one: The first car to stop should be the first car to go.

Rule number two: The first vehicle to enter the intersection should be the first one to go through it. 

Rule number three: If two or more vehicles stop simultaneously THEN THE CAR ON YOUR RIGHT GETS TO GO FIRST.  The car on your left waits for you.

Now we've cleared that up.  Happy motoring Dad.